About Houston Independent School District’s Improved Accountability Ratings
About half of Houston Independent School District schools have seen their state accountability ratings jump one or more letter grades this year, following a tumultuous first year under state-appointed Superintendent Mike Miles. The scores have significantly improved, with 149 schools improving their A to F scores by one or more letter grades.
HISD released its projected campus accountability ratings, which are still preliminary due to a temporary restraining order preventing the Texas Education Agency from releasing official 2024 ratings. Of the approximately 265 HISD schools rated, 87 schools saw no change, and 29 schools saw their scores decline.
Despite some legal challenges to the validity of the scores, HISD used the state’s methodology to calculate the ratings and chose to release them. The district’s reform model, introduced by Superintendent Myers, has shown significant progress in historically low-performing schools, with many schools improving their scores and increasing their accountability ratings.
Challenges and Controversies Surrounding Accountability Ratings
For the second year in a row, some districts in Texas are questioning the legitimacy of the state’s scores, particularly in reading. The automated scoring tool for standardized tests has been criticized for resulting in lower scores, leading to debates about the fairness and accuracy of the accountability system.
While supporters argue that the accountability system provides valuable resources and pressure to improve schools, opponents point to the potential drawbacks, such as overemphasis on standardized testing and disparities favoring wealthier communities.
HISD’s Continued Efforts and Key Takeaways
Superintendent Myers believes that the reform model is essential to bridge the equity gap between affluent and low-income students and enhance academic performance in struggling schools. The recent A to F grades highlight key takeaways, such as schools seeing improvements in their ratings and specific schools making significant progress.
Three elementary schools improved their ratings from F to A, while seven high schools that underwent overhauls showed marked improvement in their scores. Despite some community members expressing concerns about the focus on test prep, HISD remains committed to providing high-quality instruction and closing achievement gaps.
